Originally posted by plawrence: But it's funny how he offered me the less valuable pitcher for the more valuable hitter.
As stated in my first reply, I do not consider Johnson and Cuddyer to be nearly as valuable as Smoltz and Youkilis. I would not have traded them for Dye. Hernandez was added luxury I did not need. Posada's points are almost identical.... I would have given you Johnson instead of Smoltz in a second, but all you kept asking for was Carpenter, so I gave up on Dunn.
