Hmmm....

I did a little research to try and determine just how strong the Buffy Pitching Curse is on days when she & I pick the same PS.

Interesting results.

Code:
 8-10, 272 Pts, 15.1 PPG on days we had the same PS
17-30, 325 Pts,  6.9 PPG for Buffy on days when she had a different PS than PL
33-16, 823 Pts, 16.8 PPG for PL on days when he had a different PS than Buffy
So she's done considerably better than her norm on the days when she's picked the same staff as me

BUT

I've done worse than my norm on those days.

Conclusion: The Buffy Pitching Curse applies even to me, although I have been able to offset it somewhat.

"Difficult....not impossible"