I agree that New York would probably be capped out if they had both Barber and Dillon. Don't take this the wrong way, but I think Shockey gets a little more credit than necessary. Yes, he is arguably the best tight end in football, and he plays with great intensity, but he is just a tight end. That position was usually considered inferior in footall until recent years.

The Giants have great receivers in Ike Hilliard and Amani Toomer, and I think they should be the primary targets. On the other hand, a talented tight end adds a triple threat and takes pressure off the wideouts. I just can't see a TE as a team's MVP, but that's just my opinion.