Ah a nice topic
IMO i would say GoNY, it has to be one of my favorite movies in a long while, its got everything a good movie needs, although a lot of ppl disliked the ending i thought it would be better to have done what they did rather than a "The Patriot" Style simplistic ending involving a brutal fight to the death, instead Scorcese decided to show the irony of the American soldiers being the ones to disband the gangs.
Road To Perdition. An awesome movie, but really how clichewas it... Bad guy strikes good guy, good guy strikes back. Good guy in the end wins but with the cost of his life. Like i said a good movie but theres nothing there i couldnt of seen comming. Nothing special in the acting neither. Daniel Day-Lewis's performance made GoNY brilliant.