Thanks to Pogo the Clown from BlackHand Forum

Colombo Family:


?1951:
Gregory “Greg” Scarpa
Rosario “Black Sam” Nastasa


1956:
Joseph “Crazy Joe” Gallo (sponsored by John Scimone)
Lawrence “Larry” Gallo (sponsored by John Scimone)


Mid-1957: (Joe Magliocco Residence in Bath Beach, Brooklyn)
Leonard Dello
Charles “Lolly” DePierro
Lawrence Lampasi Jr.
Joseph Magnasco
Anthony “Tony Skee” Scianna


Likely candidates for the 1951 and the 1954-56 ceremonies:
Joseph Colombo
Carmine “Junior” Persico
Joseph “Joe Jelly” Gioeli
John “Sonny” Franzese
John Scimone
Joseph "Joe Yack" Yacovelli
Anthony “Abby Shots” Abbatemarco
Salvatore “Sally Pro” Profaci
Charles “Charlie Moose” Panarella
Benedetto "Benny" Aloi
Vincent “Vinny” Aloi
James 'Jimmy Ski' Scianna
Anthony 'Tony Ski' Scianna


1971: (Transferred to the Bufalino family: was made and then transferred back to the Colombo family)
Alphonse "Allie Boy" Persico


1976: (Late January/Early February)
Salvatore Albanese (sponsored by Tony Abbatemarco)
Carmine “Tutti” Franzese (sponsored by Joesph Brancato)
Salvatore “Sally” Fusco (sponsored by Joe Yacovelli)
Philip “Fat Fungi” Gambino (sponsored by Joe Yacovelli)
Joseph “Joe Black” Gorgone (sponsored by Joe Yacovelli)
Gennaro “Jerry Lang” Langella (sponsored by Persico faction)
Andrew “Andy Mush” Russo (sponsored by Persico faction)
Anthony “Scappy” Scarpati (sponsored by Charlie Panarella)
Thomas “Shorty” Spero (sponsored by Persico faction)
Dominic “Big Donnie” Somma (possibly sponsored by Joseph Brancato)


February 22-28, 1977:
Alphonse "Little Allie Boy" Persico (sponsored by Alphonse “Allie Boy” Persico)
Philip “Chubby” Rossillo (sponsored by Alphonse “Allie Boy” Persico)
Joseph "Joe T" Tomasello (sponsored by Vincent 'Vinny Sicilian' Gugliaro)
John “Johnny Irish” Matera (sponsored by Thomas DiBella)
Frank “Beansy” Melli (sponsored by Charlie Panarella)


April 29, 1977:
Micahel Bolino (Sponsored by A. Persico)
Dominic “Little Dom” Cataldo (Sponsored by J. Brancato)
Nicholas “Nicky Black” Grancio
Victor “Little Vic” Orena (Sponsored by A. Persico)
Ralph Scopo Sr. (Sponsored by J. Brancato)
Alfonso “Peanuts” Serrantonio (Sponsored by C. Panarella)
Anthony Colombo (Sponsored by A. Persico)
FNU LNU (Sponsored by R. Nastasa)


May 1977:
Angelo “Jilly” Greca


September 17, 1977:
Benedetto 'Benny' Aloi
Joseph "Junior Lollipops" Carna
+8 other members


October 1977: (Possible)
10 members (including 2 from Florida)


October 31, 1978:
Vincent "Jimmy" Angelino
Gerard “Jerry Green Eyes” Clemenza
Michael Franzese (Sponsored by J. Vitacco)
Vito Guzzo
Salvatore "Big Sal" Miciotta
John Minerva
Joseph Peraino Jr.


May 1978:
Thomas "Tom Mix/Mr. T" Farese (Sponsored by A. Persico)


August 1978
Anthony “Tony Black” Induisi


Mid 1970s-1979:
Joel "Waverly" Cacace (Pre-1979)
John “Jackie” DeRoss
Saverio “Bobby Green” Falvo
Edward Fanelli
Anthony ‘Butch” Maltese (Pre-Summer 1978)
Dominic “Donnie Shacks” Montemarano
Patsy “Junior” Palermo (Pre-Summer 1978)
Vincent Regina (1976/7)
John Pate
Nicky Rizzo (Pre-Summer 1978)
Joseph "JoJo" Russo
Anthony “Chucky” Russo
Dominic Bretti
Gregory Scarpa Jr. (1979 or 1981)
Thomas Spero Jr. - ?
?-Alphonse Cirillo


Early February 1981:
Joseph Scopo


Early April 1981:
Joseph “Joe Notch” Iannaci
+1 other member


September 1981:
Pasquale "Patty" Amato


1981:
Joseph “Joe Brewster” DeDomenico
Gregory Scarpa Jr.


Late October/Early November 1982:
Unknowns


January 1983:
Frank “Frankie Collision” Tormenia
John Saponaro
Joseph Colombo Jr.


1983:
William “Wild Bill” Cutolo (Pre-April)
William “Billy” Russo


September 1983:
Joseph “Joe Lane” Gentile


June 1986:
Robert Pate


January 1987:
Thomas "Tommy Shots" Gioeli
Theodore "Skinny Teddy" Persico Jr.
+1 other member (with the Jimmy Angellino Crew)


March 11, 1987: (Residence in Brooklyn)
Carmine Sessa
Robert "Bobby Zambooka" Zambardi
Dennis "Fat/Little/The Beard" DeLucia


July 28, 1987: (Bay Lounge, NY)
Sebastian Aloi Jr.
Victor Orena Jr.
Aurelio “Ray” Cagno (sponsored by James Randazzo)
Rocco Cagno (sponsored by James Randazzo)
+1 other member (from Brooklyn)


November 1987: (8 new members)
Victor M. Orena Jr.
Richard “Ritchie Nerves” Fusco


1987:
Vincent "Jimmy Gooch" Febbraro (Pre-March)
James “Jimmy” Randanzzo (Pre-Summer)
Vincenzo Miceli (Pre-Fall)
Ralph “Ralphie Patches” Piccirillo (Pre-Fall)


1988:
Alan Quatrache


1988: (Pre-Summer)
Richard “The Jeweller” Capichano
Joseph “Joe Smash” Gambale
Thomas Petrizzo
John S-------


December 1988: (Tommy Ocera's Merrick, Long Island restaurant)
Robert “Bob” D’Onofrio
Michael Sessa
Joseph “Joe Legs” Legrano
Lawrence “Larry Monk” Micciolo
FNU “Slatz” LNU (possibly Vincent “Schwartzie” Cascio)
+6 other members


Mid-1989:
Gioachino “Jack” Leale


Pre-Fall 1989: (Most likely the Mid 1989 ceremony)
Ralph Lombardo
Thomas “Tommy” Ocera
Henry "Hank the Bank" Smurra


December 1989: (Residence of Ralph Lombardo relative in Long Island)
Joseph "Joe Campy" Campanella
Joseph Baudanza
+1 other member


Late 1990:
Joseph Amato
Pasquale “Fat Patty” DiMatteo
Salvatore Fusco Jr.
Joseph “Joe Monte” Monteleone
Louis “Bobo” Malpeso
+5 other members


Early 1991:
Vincent “Chickie” DeMartino


Early 1991:
Frank “Frankie Camp” Campione
Daniel “Danny/The General” Persico
Ralph Scopo Jr.


May/Early June 1991:
-Several members inducted


Confirmed Inducted by May 1991:
Joseph “Chubby” Audino
Paul “Paulie Guns” Bevacqua
Salvatore “Sally Bread” Cambria
Benjamin 'Benji" Castellazzo
James “Jimmy Brown” Clemenza Jr.
Pasquale “Patty” Catalano
Gary Gugliaro
Dennis Guzzardo
Frank "Chicky" Leto
Angelo Leto
Charles Lombardo (Pre-July 1985)
Frank Melia
Charles “Charlie Fish” Miceli
Frank “Frankie Wheels” Politi
Vincent Ricciardo
John R------
Joseph Saponaro
Frank “Frankie the Bug” Sciortino
James “Jimmy O'Toole” Spitaleri


-The Colombo family was barred from making new members from late 1991-early 2000.


February 2000: (Residence in vicinity of Ave T in Gravesend, Brooklyn)
Dino "Big Dino" Calabro (sponsored by Tommy Gioeli)
Andre D’Apice
Luca DiMatteo (probably sponsored by Ralph Lombardo)
Anthony Strapoli


Early/Mid 2000:
Joseph "Joey Flowers" Rotunno


Mid 2000: (Residence in Babylon, Long Island)
Ralph DeLeo


Early 2004: (Residence on West 6th St in Gravesend, Brooklyn)
Joseph “Joey Caves” Compatiello (sponsored by Dino Calabro)
Dino "Little Dino" Saracino (sponsored by Dino Calabro)
Sebastiano “Sebby” Saracino (sponsored by Dino Calabro)
Craig “Little Craig” Marino (sponsored by Joseph Baudanza)


2005: (Apartment in Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn)
Michael "Mikey" Souza (sponsored by Dino Calabro)
Frank “Frankie BF” Sturiano


2005/6: (Residence in Greenpoint, Brooklyn)
Michael “Mike the Electrician” Catapano (sponsored by Sonny Franzese)
Vincent “Downtown Vinny” Manzo (sponsored by Tommy Gioeli)
Michael Uvino (sponsored by Vincent Ricciardo)


2006:
Carmine Baudanza (sponsored by Joseph Baudanza)
Anthony “Flemmo” Famulari (Could be Fall 2005)
?-Vincent “Big Lou” Russo (Could be 2005)


2008: (Basement of a Social Club in The Bronx)
Reynold "Ren" Maragni


February 1, 2009:
Anthony "Big Anthony" Russo
Emanuele “Manny” Favuzza
Joseph Savarese
Daniel Capaldo
John Maggio
FNU “Sally from Coney Island” LNU


January 12, 2011: (ceremony held in prison)
Illario “Fat Larry” Sessa


2013:
Jerry “Fat Jerry” Ciauri


2014:
Giovanni “John” Cerbone


2016:
Vito “Victor/The Mask” DiFalco


2011-2016:
Robert Tarantola
Phil LNU - ?


2018:-?
About half a dozen-?


December 11, 2018: (Panino Perfetto, 66 Ave. U, Gravesend, Brooklyn).
Thomas "The Plumber" Scorcia
+1 Other Individual