In either of these two scenarios:
1. If DiMeo was still alive/his crew was still active in 1985?
2. If Castellano had picked Gotti (say alongside Tommy Gambino) to be Underboss or Co-Underboss after Neil died and attended Neil's funeral? Or if say he ruled that Gotti and Gambino would be his Acting Bosses when/if he went to prison.
Roy would've been no problem. He also wanted Paul whacked. Freddie DiNome said he and Roy used to do practice hit runs on a motorcycle.