Home

Hall of Famers in Tonight's All-Star Game

Posted By: Don Sicilia

Hall of Famers in Tonight's All-Star Game - 07/14/09 05:14 PM

As I was driving into work today, I was listening to Mike and Mike and the last segment I heard before I arrived at work was how there were so many hall-of-famers in the 1971 baseball all-star game. According to M&M, there was 20 players, two managers and one coach in that game that all ended up in the hall of fame (Pete Rose was in the game as well.) My thought was "Wow!"

I didn't get to hear the segment that followed but M&M was going to go through the list of tonight's all star game and see how many potential hall of famers there are in the game. What do you guys think?

Listed below is the list of players from the 1971 game and tonight's game.

Code:
 
1971 All-Star Game
American League		National League
		
  Luis Aparicio		  Hank Aaron
  Vida Blue		  Glenn Beckert
  Don Buford		  Johnny Bench
  Leo Cardenas +	  Bobby Bonds
  Rod Carew		  Lou Brock
  Norm Cash		  Steve Carlton +
  Mike Cuellar		  Clay Carroll +
  Dave Duncan +		  Roberto Clemente
  Ray Fosse *		  Nate Colbert
  Bill Freehan		  Willie Davis
  Frank Howard		  Larry Dierker *
  Reggie Jackson	  Dock Ellis
  Al Kaline		  Bud Harrelson
  Harmon Killebrew	  Fergie Jenkins
  Mickey Lolich		  Don Kessinger
  Sam McDowell *	  Juan Marichal
  Bill Melton +		  Lee May
  Andy Messersmith +	  Willie Mays
  Thurman Munson	  Willie McCovey
  Bobby Murcer		  Felix Millan
  Tony Oliva *		  Pete Rose
  Amos Otis		  Manny Sanguillen +
  Jim Palmer		  Ron Santo
  Marty Pattin +	  Tom Seaver +
  Jim Perry +		  Willie Stargell
  Boog Powell *		  Rusty Staub +
  Brooks Robinson	  Joe Torre
  Frank Robinson	  Don Wilson
  Cookie Rojas		  Rick Wise +
  Sonny Siebert +		
  Wilbur Wood +		
  Carl Yastrzemski		



Code:
 

2009 All-Star Game Rosters		
American League
Catcher
Joe Mauer, Twins ²
Victor Martinez, Indians
Infield
1B Mark Teixeira, Yankees
1B Justin Morneau, Twins
1B Kevin Youkilis, Red Sox
1B Carlos Pena, Tampa Bay Rays (Replaces Pedroia) ²
2B Dustin Pedroia, Red Sox ¹
2B Aaron Hill, Blue Jays
SS Derek Jeter, Yankees
SS Jason Bartlett, Rays
3B Evan Longoria, Rays
3B Michael Young, Rangers
3B Brandon Inge, Tigers (Final Vote winner) ²
Outfield
Jason Bay, Red Sox
Josh Hamilton, Rangers
Ichiro Suzuki, Mariners
Carl Crawford, Rays
Curtis Granderson, Tigers
Torii Hunter, Angels ¹
Adam Jones, Orioles
Ben Zobrist, Rays
Nelson Cruz, Rangers (Replaces Hunter) ²
Pitcher
Andrew Bailey, Athletics
Josh Beckett, Red Sox
Mark Buehrle, White Sox
Brian Fuentes, Angels
Zach Greinke, Royals
Roy Halladay, Blue Jays
Felix Hernandez, Mariners
Edwin Jackson, Tigers
Joe Nathan, Twins
Jonathan Papelbon, Red Sox
Mariano Rivera, Yankees
Justin Verlander, Tigers
Tim Wakefield, Red Sox


Code:
 
2009 All-Star Game Rosters
National League
Catcher
Yadier Molina, Cardinals
Brian McCann, Braves
Infield
1B Albert Pujols, Cardinals ²
1B Prince Fielder, Brewers ²
1B Adrian Gonzalez, Padres ²
1B Ryan Howard, Phillies ²
2B Chase Utley, Phillies
2B Orlando Hudson, Dodgers
2B Freddy Sanchez, Pirates
SS Hanley Ramirez, Marlins
SS Miguel Tejada, Astros
3B David Wright, Mets
3B Ryan Zimmerman, Nationals
Outfield
Ryan Braun, Brewers
Raul Ibanez, Phillies
Carlos Beltran, Mets ¹
Brad Hawpe, Rockies
Hunter Pence, Astros
Justin Upton, Diamondbacks
Shane Victorino, Phillies (Final Vote Winner)
Jayson Werth, Phillies (Replaces Beltran)
Pitcher
Heath Bell, Padres
Chad Billingsley, Dodgers
Jonathan Broxton, Dodgers ¹
Matt Cain, Giants ¹
Francisco Cordero, Reds
Ryan Franklin, Cardinals
Dan Haren, Diamondbacks
Josh Johnson, Marlins
Ted Lilly, Cubs
Tim Lincecum, Giants
Jason Marquis, Rockies
Francisco Rodriguez, Mets
Johan Santana, Mets
Trevor Hoffman, Brewers (Replaces Broxton)
Zach Duke, Pirates (Replaces Cain)

Posted By: Sicilian Babe

Re: Hall of Famers in Tonight's All-Star Game - 07/14/09 05:26 PM

IMO, from the AL team: Jeter (I know, you're all surprised), Papelbon, Rivera, Mauer and Youkilis. I might consider adding Longoria, Beckett and Halladay to that list. On the NL side, I only see Santana with HoF potential, but I'm biased as an AL gal.
Posted By: Don Sicilia

Re: Hall of Famers in Tonight's All-Star Game - 07/14/09 05:52 PM

The whole issue gets a little bit muddied up by the steroid era - I don't see any obvious steroid names but I don't think the last shoe has dropped on the 2003 tests either.

From the NL side, besides Santana, Pujols will probably end up as a first ballot guy.
Posted By: BAM_233

Re: Hall of Famers in Tonight's All-Star Game - 07/14/09 06:17 PM

if he is clean he will be a 1st time inductee...and i think tim lincecum will be in the hall as well...if he continues the way he is performing, and injuries dont make a big impact like other young pitchers i.e kerry wood and mark prior
Posted By: Don Sicilia

Re: Hall of Famers in Tonight's All-Star Game - 07/14/09 06:26 PM

For body of work across Japan and the U.S., Ichiro is probably a hall-of-famer.
Posted By: BAM_233

Re: Hall of Famers in Tonight's All-Star Game - 07/14/09 06:34 PM

yea he is...i wonder though with this hall of fame talk...what happends if a known steroid user like clemens, sosa, mcgwire, or bonds get in...will this mean every cheater gets in? along with that will shoeless joe and rose get in if others who damaged the game gets in
Posted By: SC

Re: Hall of Famers in Tonight's All-Star Game - 07/14/09 06:45 PM

Look at the names of those who hit home runs in that game:

Clemente, Aaron, Bench, F.Robinson, Killebrew, Jackson.

(Reggie Jackson's shot was over 550 feet).

I'd say that's some list!!!
Posted By: ronnierocketAGO

Re: Hall of Famers in Tonight's All-Star Game - 07/14/09 08:42 PM

2009 AL

Guaranteed: Mariano Rivera, Ichiri Suzuki (arguably the best player of this decade)
Probably: Derek Jeter*
At this rate: Joe Mauer, Tori Hunter

2009 NL

Guaranteed: Trevor Hoffman
At this rate: Albert Pujols, Prince Fielder, Ryan Howard, Johan Santana.

*=Before some of you knee-jerk YES, consider that Don Mattingly (former AL MVP) and Alan Trammell aren't in the HOF.
Posted By: SC

Re: Hall of Famers in Tonight's All-Star Game - 07/15/09 01:46 AM

I was a little surprised at the crowd's reaction to Stan Musial being introduced. Sure, he got a standing ovation but it was somewhat subdued.
Posted By: Freddie C.

Re: Hall of Famers in Tonight's All-Star Game - 07/15/09 03:00 PM

NL: Pujols, Hoffman, Utley, Santana, Howard, Wright, Fielder, Ramirez, Braun, Lincecum, McCann, Rodriguez

AL: Jeter, Ichiro, Rivera, Mauer, Halladay, Hernandez, Morneau, Crawford, Papelbon
Posted By: klydon1

Re: Hall of Famers in Tonight's All-Star Game - 07/15/09 05:46 PM

Originally Posted By: Freddie C.
NL: Pujols, Hoffman, Utley, Santana, Howard, Wright, Fielder, Ramirez, Braun, Lincecum, McCann, Rodriguez

AL: Jeter, Ichiro, Rivera, Mauer, Halladay, Hernandez, Morneau, Crawford, Papelbon



At this moment Jeter, Ichiro and Rivera would be elected from the AL, and although he has a long way to go, I'd bet Pujols would get in if his career were to end today.

Hoffman, the career leader in saves, is a question mark. The Hall has been very selective about closers and points out that Gossage and Sutter would pitch 2 and three innings for saves where the closers today seldom go beyond three outs.

Randy Johnson and Ken Griffey, Jr., John Smoltz (and pretty soon) Pedro Martinez are present players, who are locks for the Hall. A-Rod and Ramirez have to join the group that includes McGwire, Bonds and Sosa. I also expect Jim Thome to be inducted.

There are a lot of young players having fantastic careers, who have to keep doing it for another 7-10 years to join the conversation.
© 2024 GangsterBB.NET