Michael Corleone versus...

Tony Montana. I'm not sure where this thread should fit, but....

I've always thought about this. Who would win in a war between the Corleone Family when Michael is the Don and the Tony Montana regime from Miami?

I would easily say Michael Corleone. The Italians would destroy the Cuban/Colombian faction.

In a fist fight? I would still say Michael Corleone. Tony Montana could assassinate people with a knife, but Michael knew how to box and really fight. Besides, Coreleone was in Sicily for a year. Sicily is a hundred times more dangerous than Havana or Miami.

I'm sure Mike picked up some hand-to-hand combat tips in the military. He wins in the fistfight.

Another reason is when you're in a fight, you have to keep composure, not be so wild. Tony would go crazy and hurt himself

michael win, tony was wild and impulsive , michael have more brain, and better way to atack.

I say Michael as well. The Corleone family is stronger than Tony's regime ever will be. michael is smarter than Tony Montana as well.

The Corleone family would win in the outcome against Montana's Cuban gang. As for Colombian drug cartels that Tony's connected too? Not a chance.

The Corleone family, hands down. Tony Montana was a maniac, as many of you have said. Mike was a Marine, and he's an efficient killer, as he proved in the films. The strong arm of the Corleone family reaches as far as Sicily, as shown when Michael got a hold of Frankie's brother in Part II. Mike could have Tony killed in his sleep, before he even left Miami.

Definatly Michael. Tony would have no chance. The Corleones are better structured than the Cubans.Fist fight, Mike again. Tony was too wild and probably would have worn himself out.

as far as a gun battle we know who would win

"You wanna play rough?!"
i reckon Tony Montana would win in a fist fight, hed get a bit coked up, a bit sick i the head and would anihilate anyone.

In a power battle the Corleone Family would have it.

Now post in the Scarface forum,I'll bet every one says Tony'd win!

Michael is more calculating than Tony is. Michael thinks about everything excessively before he does it. The Corleone family is also portrayed as extremely powerful and organized. Tony's organization makes a lot of money, but his organization's power does not extend nearly as far as the Corleone family power does. So, Michael wins in war, but loses in a fistfight, 'cause Tony is f@$&%n crazy, and wouldn't go down as easy. He must have taken at least 75 bullets at the end of Scarface.

depending what the situation is, or actually i should say, if these two were to ever stumble upon each for whatever reason, i'd give tony about a few hours to live...

True

True

easily: MIKE

Neither. It would take too long to properly clone Pacino, and by then, he wouldn't be fit to play either role, whichever he chose.