I don't think that the committee would have been able to pursue a case against Micheal at all had they just gone on Cicci's testimony. So my question is did he violate the laws of omerta?
They couldn't pursue a case against Michael based on Willie Cicci's testimony alone. That's why they got Frankie Five Angles to corroborate Cicci's testimony. They needed the testimony of BOTH in order to pursue a legal case against Michael.
But Frankie reneges once the Corleone's produce his brother at the trial, thus making Cici's testimony meaningless.
Now as far as Cici breaking the law of omerta, well of course he did. However when giving his testimony he may have actually helped Michael more than hurt him.
---------------------------------------------
CHAIRMAN: "Did you ever get such an order directly from MICHAEL Corleone."
CICCI: "No -- I never talked to him."
GEARY: "Could you expand on your answer -- I'm particularly interested in knowing -- uh -- was there always a buffer involved -- -- someone between you and your possible superiors, who gave the actual order?"
CICCI: "Right, yea a buffer -- the family had a lot of buffers."
---------------------------------------
So in truth, Cicci did not implicate Michael in any illegal activities because he testified that he had never received a direct order from Michael and there were always inbetween men, buffers, that gave Cicci the orders that
possibly were sent down by Michael.
That kind of testimony, if it even makes it to trial, is eaten alive by any lawyer worth his salt. It's pure hearsay if Cicci testifies that Tessio told him that Michael Corleone was the one who told him to pass the order on to Cicci.
I believe that Michael made Pentangeli pay the price for himself and Willie Cicci. After all Cicci was Frankie's boy and Michael probably held Frankie responsible for one of his own guys turning rat.
However I've always felt that FFC should have included some kind of scene where Willie Cicci was "paid back" by the Corleones for turning on them.
After all Michael said that he didn't feel that he had to wipe everyone out -- just his enemies. And as far as I am concerned Willie Cicci became an enemy.