Home

Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time

Posted By: J Geoff

Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time - 07/30/07 08:00 PM


There's a contest to determine which UBB-based forum has the best "content", and I need to submit 3 threads from here that "exemplify" Gangster BB.

I'm thinking Plaw's memorial thread should be one of them. I'm also thinking one of the 3 threads should be related to the forum's theme... and maybe one should have lots of pictures (perhaps from one of the get-togethers?)

Any other ideas? Please post links to your favorite threads of all time




Posted By: long_lost_corleone

Re: Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time - 07/30/07 08:15 PM

The three best threads of all time, in no order:

-Happy 16th Birthday long_lost_corleone
-Happy Birthday, LLC!
-LLC! Happy Next Birthday!
Posted By: J Geoff

Re: Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time - 07/30/07 08:18 PM


Thanks for your help! \:p
Posted By: Turnbull

Re: Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time - 07/30/07 08:19 PM

Geoff,
I agree with you about the plaw memorial and photos from get-togethers. They show the unique civility and cameraderie we've achieved on these boards.
As for a thread related to theme: I think you should choose one from GFII that shows how deeply we get into the complexity of the plot. I suggest you choose the best in your opinion that deals with the recurring questions: who killed the Tahoe shooters, did Roth engineer Frankie's survival, Geary's sources in finding out that Michael was moving Klingman out, did Fredo know it was gonna be a hit, did Connie know Michael whacked Fredo. Or a "moral" question: Did Fredo deserve to die, was Vito a better Don than Michael.
Posted By: SC

Re: Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time - 07/30/07 08:23 PM

1.The Chicago convention thread linked below. Lots of pix and comments:
CHICAGO CONVENTION


2. One of the "five or six Families" debates... this one (below) has a little of everything in it:

5 or 6 Families Debate
Posted By: svsg

Re: Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time - 07/30/07 09:18 PM

How about Cereal Poll \:\) ?

EDIT: Wow, I think I must be the first one to use a smiley in the URL \:D
Posted By: Mignon

Re: Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time - 07/30/07 09:19 PM

1. SC's scrapbook
Posted By: Irishman12

Re: Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time - 07/30/07 09:33 PM

The movies or Yankees threads \:p
Posted By: svsg

Re: Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time - 07/30/07 09:34 PM

 Originally Posted By: Irishman12
The movies or Yankees threads \:p

I second that \:\)
Posted By: Don Cardi

Re: Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time - 07/30/07 09:41 PM

The Chicago Convention.

Plaw's Memorial Thread.

Who killed The Assassins.

(I know that there have been several Tahoe assassain discussions over the years but I think that you should choose from one of the very earlier discussions that were pretty deep and complex)
Posted By: Beth E

Re: Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time - 07/30/07 09:57 PM

Is the original 9/11 thread still active on this board? I'd pick that one along with plaw's memorial thread and the Mama Corleone is dead thread.
Posted By: DE NIRO

Re: Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time - 07/30/07 10:03 PM

I think one from each of the main forums..

-Who killed The Assassins.-From GF Section

-Mob myths, facts and realities -OC Section

-REMEMBERING PLAWRENCE... -GD Section

i was ganna include the Numbers games, but i thought not.
Posted By: Mignon

Re: Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time - 07/30/07 10:20 PM

Plaw's "The Night Before Christmas" Godfather Version

Or

Making Fun Of Our Members
Posted By: ronnierocketAGO

Re: Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time - 07/30/07 11:45 PM

Anything started by yours truely.
Posted By: pizzaboy

Re: Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time - 07/30/07 11:47 PM

 Originally Posted By: ronnierocketAGO
Anything started by yours truely.


How about your Oscar thread that you ended up boycotting? \:p
Posted By: klydon1

Re: Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time - 07/30/07 11:56 PM

Have we all forgotten The Female Hotties Thread? \:p
Posted By: Irishman12

Re: Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time - 07/31/07 12:16 AM

 Originally Posted By: klydon1
Have we all forgotten The Female Hotties Thread? \:p


klydon, oh how could I forget? I knew I wasn't the only male member who enjoys it \:p \:D
Posted By: The Italian Stallionette

Re: Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time - 07/31/07 12:52 AM

That's great Geoff!

I'll have to think about it more, but I agree with any thread in which we discuss one of our unanswered GF questions is good. You are right about showing the detail we have gone into disucssing these topics. I think it's show just how big of fans we are.

Btw, I am always happy to hear these kinds of contests and/or of your appearances on the radio and such. I think you deserve the recognition for all your hard work. ;\) In your spare time can you give us more info on who's putting on this contest, is there a prize; and when/where will results be posted???

Good luck Geoff. I don't need to see the other entries..in my book you are already the winner!!! ;\)

TIS
Posted By: ronnierocketAGO

Re: Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time - 07/31/07 01:17 AM

 Originally Posted By: pizzaboy
 Originally Posted By: ronnierocketAGO
Anything started by yours truely.


How about your Oscar thread that you ended up boycotting? \:p


Oh you mean the one that I quit after some people in power started being assholes in it? Yeah, maybe a candidate in itself.
Posted By: MaryCas

Re: Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time - 07/31/07 01:24 AM

How about the thread that explained that I wasn't a woman?
Posted By: The Italian Stallionette

Re: Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time - 07/31/07 01:32 AM

Ha ha!! I remember that. I think you took everyone by surprise. How long had you been posting on the BB before that shocking announcement?

You'll always be Mary to me!! \:p

TIS
Posted By: klydon1

Re: Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time - 07/31/07 02:22 AM

This thread is fast becoming one of the three all-time greats.
Posted By: J Geoff

Re: Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time - 07/31/07 02:52 AM


I'm starting to think maybe "Random Post Whoring" deserves a mention... what better exemplifies the BB? \:D

I could always add a 4th I suppose ;\)
Posted By: Sicilian Babe

Re: Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time - 07/31/07 02:50 PM

How about the one started for Lebo's new edition of The Godfather Legacy? There were some really terrific and insightful posts.
Posted By: J Geoff

Re: Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time - 07/31/07 04:49 PM


Not a bad idea - it'd probably be more interesting to non-fans who are voting...
Posted By: Blibbleblabble

Re: Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time - 08/01/07 04:45 AM

 Originally Posted By: svsg
How about Cereal Poll \:\) ?


Wow, I'm honored that one of my pointless threads was even mentioned in this thread!
Posted By: J Geoff

Re: Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time - 08/01/07 06:29 PM


Here's my entry -- I'll let you know how we do in a few weeks! Thanks for your input!

 Quote:



My community is generally for fans of Mob films and shows (The Godfather, Scarface, The Sopranos, etc), author Mario Puzo, as well as the Mafia in general. The forum (in UBB format) began in 2001 -- we just celebrated our 6th anniversary with UBB -- and for most of those years, I consciously didn't promote the site, because I felt we were "worth" the find thru my main websites. The forum has attracted an eclectic membership (male/female, young/old), and most are well-behaved. lol We've even had the pleasure of Mario Puzo's wife, Carol Gino, answering questions about their last book after he died.

The community has been so tight, we've been holding annual in-person weekends with a dozen or so members, many traveling across country, even bringing their families. In addition, many of us in the New York area get together a few times a year for dinner. Many life-long friendships have come out of it. We actually lost a close friend last year who came into our lives directly through our community, as presented below.

The links that best exemplify my forums are:

a. Godfather Legacy - Shooting Locations - Author Harlan Lebo ("The Godfather Legacy") recruited my members for some info on his revised book. It was tough to pick one thread about the movie content of all the many in depth discussions that've been held, but I thought this would be the most interesting to non-fans.

b. Greetings from Chicago! - Our first annual get-together in 2004 was a lot of fun! Includes pictures of us with some Sopranos actors, and some great stories if you have the time to go thru it.

c. REMEMBERING PLAWRENCE... - A tribute to a dear friend met online who passed away. This really shows the camaraderie

Besides the main content of mob-related entertainment, what I think sets this forum apart from many others are the real-life friendships that have come out of it, so I focused a bit on that. There are plenty of other main-content threads you can explore.

Thanks,

JG
Posted By: Turnbull

Re: Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time - 08/01/07 06:54 PM

Excellent entry, Geoff! \:\)
Posted By: SC

Re: Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time - 08/01/07 06:59 PM

 Originally Posted By: J Geoff

Here's my entry -- I'll let you know how we do in a few weeks! Thanks for your input!


What other boards are you up against?
Posted By: Beth E

Re: Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time - 08/01/07 07:03 PM

What's the prize?
Posted By: J Geoff

Re: Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time - 08/01/07 07:06 PM


I'm only the 3rd entry so far (it just started), and it continues for the next 2 weeks.
I don't anticipate many entries, but they'll appear here...

Of course since people will be visiting here from that site, I expect no bad-mouthing of other forums... ;\)
Posted By: J Geoff

Re: Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time - 08/01/07 07:09 PM

 Originally Posted By: Beth E
What's the prize?

No trips or cars or anything, if that's what you mean. \:D An "award" image, a link to here, a couple pieces of software -- and pride. ;\)
Posted By: Beth E

Re: Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time - 08/02/07 12:29 AM

 Originally Posted By: J Geoff



Of course since people will be visiting here from that site,


Hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm. Strangers will be watching. Does that mean we need to be dressed while we're at the computer?
Posted By: The Italian Stallionette

Re: Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time - 08/02/07 12:47 AM

Wow, how interesting. One an English automobiles and NJ fishing conditions and GF. I can imagine they will get a very wide variety of topics. It's really wonderful (and amazing) how easy it is to get info on any topic anywhere in the world. \:o

Wouldn't it be a kick in the pants if someone else had a GF BB and entered??? \:o Nah!!! Anything else would be simply mediocre. ;\)

I imagine we will get some new members from this no? Good luck Geoff. \:\)


TIS
Posted By: Sicilian Babe

Re: Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time - 08/02/07 01:13 AM

Geoff, keeping fingers crossed for you. It would be well-deserved, my friend.

BTW, what a pleasure to read through some of those posts, especially Plaw's. I almost wet my pants when I read, "SC, I hear you left Chicago in stitches."
Posted By: Don Sicilia

Re: Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time - 08/02/07 02:00 PM

Great entry, JG. Good luck! \:\)
Posted By: Mignon

Re: Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time - 08/03/07 12:02 AM

Best of luck to ya Geoff. I'm rooting for ya.
Posted By: Beth E

Re: Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time - 08/03/07 12:12 AM

 Originally Posted By: Mignon
I'm rooting for ya.


I'm not.

Just kidding. You know I luv ya Geoff. \:p
Posted By: klydon1

Re: Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time - 08/03/07 02:07 AM

Good luck, Geoff. Is it too late to enter the thread where you make the little penguin ride his sled down the hill. That was the thread that got me hooked.
Posted By: Capo de La Cosa Nostra

Re: Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time - 08/03/07 02:03 PM

After "eclectic", I would have added "international". Cool entry, though. Good luck! \:\)
Posted By: Capo de La Cosa Nostra

Re: Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time - 08/03/07 02:03 PM

By the way, I suppose this is to be expected from speciality forums, but Christ, fishing?
Posted By: Mignon

Re: Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time - 09/24/07 11:56 PM

Geoff,

Whatever came of this?
Posted By: J Geoff

Re: Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time - 09/25/07 12:25 AM


Hey, Miggy... they haven't even announced the winner(s) yet, but I don't think we won cuz they're waiting on the winners' interviews... Ahh, well, but thanks everyone! We're all still wieners!! \:D
Posted By: DonMichaelCorleone

Re: Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time - 09/25/07 12:27 AM

There weren't any submissions with many contributions from DMC, I wonder if that had anything to do with it....
Posted By: SC

Re: Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time - 09/25/07 12:45 AM

 Originally Posted By: DonMichaelCorleone
There weren't any submissions with many contributions from DMC, I wonder if that had anything to do with it....


I thought that was one of the strong points of Geoff's choices. \:p
Posted By: DonMichaelCorleone

Re: Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time - 09/25/07 12:59 AM

 Originally Posted By: SC
 Originally Posted By: DonMichaelCorleone
There weren't any submissions with many contributions from DMC, I wonder if that had anything to do with it....


I thought that was one of the strong points of Geoff's choices. \:p


Apparently not strong enough \:p
Posted By: Blibbleblabble

Re: Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time - 09/25/07 03:23 AM

I don't think I was in any of those threads either.
Posted By: J Geoff

Re: Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time - 09/26/07 06:52 PM


The winners have been announced and GangsterBB got Honorable Mention. Not bad... at least Top 4 is better than Bottom 4 \:D
Posted By: Turnbull

Re: Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time - 09/26/07 07:24 PM

Whadda they know? We're still the top!
Posted By: Don Cardi

Re: Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time - 09/26/07 07:38 PM

Honorable mention. Sheesh! What do they know? Bunch of pezzanovantes!
Posted By: SC

Re: Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time - 09/26/07 08:00 PM

We got beat out by a bunch of homesick Aussies???? \:o

Posted By: Mignon

Re: Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time - 09/26/07 09:16 PM

Sorry Geoffy. Do you know how many sites were entered?
Posted By: Signor Vitelli

Re: Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time - 09/27/07 12:54 AM

Phooey!

We wuz robbed.

Signor V.
Posted By: Sicilian Babe

Re: Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time - 09/27/07 01:05 AM

 Originally Posted By: Mignon
Sorry Geoffy. Do you know how many sites were entered?


Four \:p
Posted By: The Italian Stallionette

Re: Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time - 09/27/07 01:49 AM

Well, what do they know? You're site is number one with us. You should be very proud of what you've got here Geoff. Look how we all flock here to this site; to kick back and have fun. Ain't nothing to sneeze at!!! \:D

TIS
Posted By: long_lost_corleone

Re: Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time - 09/27/07 01:59 AM

 Originally Posted By: The Italian Stallionette
Ain't nothing to sneeze at!!! \:D


That's easily the coolest expression I've heard since "do you smell what I'm stepping in?" \:D
Posted By: The Italian Stallionette

Re: Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time - 09/27/07 02:11 AM

 Originally Posted By: long_lost_corleone
 Originally Posted By: The Italian Stallionette
Ain't nothing to sneeze at!!! \:D


That's easily the coolest expression I've heard since "do you smell what I'm stepping in?" \:D


Ha ha. I never heard that expression!! But, I get your drift. \:\)

TIS


Posted By: Blibbleblabble

Re: Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time - 09/27/07 02:22 AM

You mean there are three better sites than this one!?!?



Well screw this place! I'm off to one of the better sites! ;\)

That contest was rigged... Did you forget to pay off the officials Geoff?
Posted By: DonMichaelCorleone

Re: Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time - 09/27/07 02:42 AM

 Originally Posted By: Blibbleblabble
I don't think I was in any of those threads either.


Are you trying to compare yourself to me Blibble? I wish there was a movie made that put what I want to say right now into some kind of quote. If there was such a quote I'd love to just post it and say "Blibble, we're both pretty much the same person, but don't think that something that applies to you should apply to me, Senator."
Posted By: Blibbleblabble

Re: Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time - 09/27/07 03:10 AM

 Originally Posted By: DonMichaelCorleone
 Originally Posted By: Blibbleblabble
I don't think I was in any of those threads either.


Are you trying to compare yourself to me Blibble? I wish there was a movie made that put what I want to say right now into some kind of quote. If there was such a quote I'd love to just post it and say "Blibble, we're both pretty much the same person, but don't think that something that applies to you should apply to me, Senator."


Posted By: Mike Sullivan

Re: Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time - 09/30/07 06:09 AM

Shakespeare v. Tupac
Posted By: svsg

Re: Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time - 09/30/07 06:28 AM

 Originally Posted By: Mike Sullivan
Shakespeare v. Tupac

I have seen numerous references to this thread, but haven't read it. Can anyone point me to it or is it deleted (I can't find it in search)?
Posted By: Blibbleblabble

Re: Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time - 09/30/07 06:29 AM

For some reason I'm guessing Patrick was involved with that thread.
Posted By: Don Andrew

Re: Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time - 09/30/07 02:40 PM

 Originally Posted By: svsg
 Originally Posted By: Mike Sullivan
Shakespeare v. Tupac

I have seen numerous references to this thread, but haven't read it. Can anyone point me to it or is it deleted (I can find it in search)?


Man, I want to see that thread too. It's just so legendary and I think it's been deleted. Sadly before my time. \:\(
Posted By: Mike Sullivan

Re: Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time - 10/06/07 01:46 AM

Indeed he was. I miss that whigger sometimes... usually when I want to beat something into a bloody pulp.

Saddest moment in history, really.
Posted By: Blibbleblabble

Re: Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time - 10/07/07 06:23 PM

 Originally Posted By: Don Andrew
 Originally Posted By: svsg
 Originally Posted By: Mike Sullivan
Shakespeare v. Tupac

I have seen numerous references to this thread, but haven't read it. Can anyone point me to it or is it deleted (I can find it in search)?


Man, I want to see that thread too. It's just so legendary and I think it's been deleted. Sadly before my time. \:\(


I tried searching for it with no luck... has it really been deleted?
Posted By: SC

Re: Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time - 10/07/07 06:56 PM

 Originally Posted By: Blibbleblabble
I tried searching for it with no luck... has it really been deleted?


Apparently. It was not done because of any subject matter, though. Some of the General Discussion threads were lost from 2003 and 2004 when space was needed for newer topics. (Most of the General threads before 2003 had been deleted for that same reason).
Posted By: J Geoff

Re: Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time - 10/07/07 08:13 PM


I don't recall deleting it, though... if so, it was by mistake probably... \:\/
Posted By: Blibbleblabble

Re: Need your help: 3 "Best" threads of all time - 10/07/07 08:42 PM

That's too bad those threads were randomly deleted during that time... I don't know much about running a BB, but I guess I just ASSumed everything was saved. \:\(
© 2024 GangsterBB.NET