Originally posted by Don Cardi:
ponder this : I think that Barzini DID have the approval of the commission. At the commission meeting requested by Vito, we hear Barzini make his famous speach about how Vito would not share his political connections and how this is not an act of a friend, etc. Barzini is addressing the whole commission and there is not a single sign of ANY of those commission members objecting to what Barzini is saying. Not one family that was part of that commission took the side of The Corleone's during the war.
Don Cardi Originally posted by UnderBoss:
Personally I have always felt that FFC added the killing of the other commission dons for this reason alone as the book only features the killing of Barzini and Tattaglia and this wouldn’t’ have been as coherent with the reality of the situation.
DC and UB: You both make a strong case. An alternative view is that Barzini and Tattaglia gave their partner, Sollozzo, permission to whack the Don without asking the other Dons--Cuneo and Stracci. They were neutral because they regarded it as a conflict between the Corleones and Barzini/Tattaglia/Sollozzo. They had no need to get involved in a risky situation. But, when Michael whacked Sollozzo and McCluskey, he brought down a huge load of heat from the police, which severely cramped Mob operations. That's when they took sides against the Corleones.
N.B.: The real life role of the Commission in approving hits is at best dubious. We know that the Commission voted to remove Joe Bonanno from his Donship. But, as far as is known, Vito Genovese didn't consult the Commission about attempting to whack Frank Costello or about assassinating Albert Anastasia. In fact, the famous Apalachin meeting of 1957 was called, in part, to legitimize Carlo Gambino as Anastasia's successor, and to anoint Genovese as capo di tutti capi. To this day, no one knows exactly who gave the order to shoot Joe Columbo--many think Gambino ordered it, but who knows if he consulted the Commission. Gotti didn't ask the Commission's permission to whack Paul Castellano (though he did lobby key Commission members after the fact). We don't know if Chin Gigante asked the Commission's permission to attempt to kill Gotti (the car bombing that killed Frankie DiCicco instead).