Geary at the brothel

Do you think that what happened with Geary and the prostitue at Fredo's brothel was engineered by the Corleones?

Now you're joking, right?

Duh!

Have I just been really stupid? Not having read the book I was unsure about the situation...

Can anyone shed some light on what exactly happened?

The book doesn't say anything about this. I recommend you rewatch the scene very closely as it reveals all you need to know.

Neri washing his hands in the bathroom!! Can't believe I never noticed this!

Is this one of the very few times where we are shown explicitly the lack of morality/ethics from the Corleone family?

The other acts of violence commited by the family are , in my mind atleast, quite justified, always directed towards people that had it coming to them.

In this situation, I suppose because she is a whore we are inclined to feel less emotion or sympathy towards her?

Apologies again for my initial stupid question. I'll make sure I do my research properly next time before starting a new thread!!

I always wondered how a professional like Neri could be so stupid as to allow himself to be seen by Geary in that scene.
Maybe it was a cineatic device to show the audience who killed the prostitute.

As for killing people who had it coming to them, apparently hookers are the exception to the Corleones. Remember in I they killed a hooker who was with Tattaglia.

Where does it show that Geary sees Neri?

We the viewer see him, but I don't think Geary sees or notices him. The only reason they show him is to make sure we the viewers know that he has been set up.

Killing the hooker was a very small price to pay to hook Geary.

Yeah, hookers were 'infamia' yet Sonny was banging one.

I misspoke, sorry. Geary never saw Neri, but thats only because Tom gave him a dirty look, and Geary went back into hiding.

You know, even if he did see Neri,

For all that Geary would know is that Neri was there to help clean up this mess of his, as he already may have seen Neri from the vist in Michaels office. After all I trust these men with my life senator....
and now they are there to fix your screw up mess!


The real item is, how was Neri feeling about all this and Geary. It always seem to me that Neri looked down on Geary and stood around like he was saying take that you little piece of shit! Now who is King Shit....

Whether born that way or evolved that way, Neri was a murderer plain and simple.

Hookers and horses!!

That's exactly it DT. Otherwise, we are left with Geary's truncated comments about how it happened which might not make much sense to an audience. It always cements the conspiratotial links between the murder and Michael's intent.