Originally posted by DarthMalo:
Weren't also the hits on the heads of the five families supposed to mirror the hits made by Lucky Luciano?
Welcome to the boards, DarthMalo! Good question!
There is an enduring perception that, in the 1931 time frame, the famous Castellemmarese War among Mafia families was settled during a so-called "Night of the Sicilian Vespers," in which a bloodbath took place, leaving Charlie Luciano as the undisputed
capo di tutti capi. It didn't happen that way at all:
In 1930, Joe (the Boss) Masseria declared himself
capo di tutti capi. To reinforce his claim, he arranged the murder of a Castellemmarese Don and demanded a tribute from another in Brooklyn. That guy paid and fled, leaving Salvatore Maranzano in charge. A protracted war ensued, with plenty of shootings, but no out-and-out massacres. Luciano was Masseria's #2 guy at the time. Maranzano flattered, cajoled and ultimately tortured Luciano into betraying his boss. Luciano recruited a hit squad organized by Meyer Lansky, which killed Masseria in a Brooklyn restaurant. Maranzano made Luciano head of Masseria's family. Then Maranzano made a fatal mistake: he declared
himself capo di tutti capi. He called a meeting of some 600 NYC-area Mafiosi, organized them into five families, and demanded a monthly tribute from each. This didn't sit well with the younger guys, who looked to Luciano for help. Luciano reached for Lansky, who organized another hit squad. Posing as Treasury agents, they burst into Maranzano's office in the Grand Central building and demanded to see his books. As he was complying, they shot and stabbed him to death. (Ironically, at that very moment, Vincent (Mad Dog) Coll, a freelance killer whom Maranzano had hired to kill Luciano, was entering the building for his last instructions from Maranzano!). Luciano had the good sense not to declare himself
capo di tutti capi. Instead, he formed the Commission, and became its
de facto head, with Lansky as the Commission's unofficial
consigliere. That's a long way of saying: plenty of blood, but no equivalent of the Five Families Massacre of 1955 as depicted in GF.