Who here would trade the actor Robert Iler with unknown actor John Milano [ http://www.geocities.com/connections901/milano.html ], they're the same age, for the character A.J. ???

Someone brought it up at my college and we were talking about it, thought that was pretty interesting question.

- ST

It would be easier than replacing someone like,Carmella,but after 4 years,I don't think it's worth it.It's not like his acting is bad.

First of all Welcome ST!!

I agree with M4M that it would be easier to replace someone like AJ than Carmella. I think I could adapt to a different AJ, since his role is not that significant as of yet.

However, I don't know why they'd replace him. We are all use to him and he isn't a bad actor. If they decided to make a swith with AJ, it wouldn't bother me. if they ever replaced Tony,however, that would be a different story .Then show would go down the tubes as far as I'm concerned.

TIS

if they replaced tony i would take the part